monsterfish studio
New Member
- Messages
- 6
Recently photo shoot these two species and I'm new here.Enjoy!
With the normal disclaimer I think they are Apistogramma ortegai, some discussion of which form is here <"Apistogramma sp. Roca..." >.Wow! If only I had access to such high quality fish! Which species are they?
Species in the eunotus-complex, probably ortegai (formerly Pebas)-subcomplex. Without seeing the dark markings on the fish, it is hard to identify.
First, "A. algodon II" is a 'garbage name' used for the past 20 years for a mix of closely related species that are collected around Pebas, Peru: A. ortegai (Papagei), A. cf. ortegai (Pebas) and A. sp. Putumayo (Ampiyacu). If these fish are domestic bred specimens, then they could be a hybrid or, if the breeder is lucky, a pure species.
Second, I did not write that the fish is either A. eunotus or A. ortegai. I wrote that the fish belongs to a species-complex that contains many different species. I split this species-complex into 3 sub-complexes:
ortegai-subcomplex ---
cruzi-subcomplex --- eunotus-complex\
eunotus-subcomplex---/
I know that the fish in the photo are not A. eunotus. A. eunotus - the true species - is not in the trade/hobby and has not been for about 30 years. The fish in the middle photo looks like A. ortegai (Papagei) to me, but the other 2 photos show a fish that is a different species. These fish could belong to either either the cruzi-subcomplex or ortegai-subcomplex. I need to see the shape of the caudal spot to be sure. I would sell them as "A. sp. Algodon II". Hobbyists knowledgeable about apistos will understand the name.
Mike, I'd like to ask you if you are against buying A. Algodon. I could get my hands on them and they look pretty nice too, but will I face problems with the fry, if their parents are indeed hybrids/mixed fish?First, "A. algodon II" is a 'garbage name' used for the past 20 years for a mix of closely related species that are collected around Pebas, Peru: A. ortegai (Papagei), A. cf. ortegai (Pebas) and A. sp. Putumayo (Ampiyacu). If these fish are domestic bred specimens, then they could be a hybrid or, if the breeder is lucky, a pure species.
Second, I did not write that the fish is either A. eunotus or A. ortegai. I wrote that the fish belongs to a species-complex that contains many different species. I split this species-complex into 3 sub-complexes:
ortegai-subcomplex ---
cruzi-subcomplex --- eunotus-complex\
eunotus-subcomplex---/
I know that the fish in the photo are not A. eunotus. A. eunotus - the true species - is not in the trade/hobby and has not been for about 30 years. The fish in the middle photo looks like A. ortegai (Papagei) to me, but the other 2 photos show a fish that is a different species. These fish could belong to either either the cruzi-subcomplex or ortegai-subcomplex. I need to see the shape of the caudal spot to be sure. I would sell them as "A. sp. Algodon II". Hobbyists knowledgeable about apistos will understand the name.
Thanks for the reply,I'm not against buying any fish if you like them. Most apisto hobbyists love 2X/3X red cocatoos, but I've never had an interest in or kept any domestic red A. cacatuoides. I do keep a wild population, however. Personally, I wouldn't buy Algodon unless I knew that they were wildcaught and I could pick out my own fish. Then I could get only the species that I wanted. But that is just me. I'm a crotchety old dude!![]()
Again, thank you very much for your valuable help.It really depends on which species (1 or 2) are used for breeding. Algodons are commonly available so the fish, if hybrids, seem to be mostly viable - or maybe only the Algodons fry bred from a single species survive. I just don't know. If commercially bred in a group setting each species will preferentially seek out its own species. If bred as pairs, well "any port in a storm".