Viejita or Macmasteri?

[Mburz]

Hi all. These fish were labeled as A. viejita 'Red Neck'. I have been told and have read that they are most likely to be A. macmasteri. They may be too young to tell for sure but any opinions are welcome.

The fish in pic 1 is around 35mm TL and the other is -30mm TL.
I must clean that glass:redface:

 

[Bilbo]

I hope Mike posts on this but as he is far more reliable than me but for me they are 2 young male macmasteri.

But I am only 75% sure about the ID and 50% sure about the sex :wink:

I really do hope I am wrong about both though.

 

[Mburz]

I thought two males too. I got two more today that were the most feminine of the four at the LFS but too young to be sure yet.

 

[shoshone]

For the sex,they are too young to tell.
For the id, i join the others,they are macmasteri.
Are they in the same tank ?

 

[Mburz]

Yes, same tank.

 

[shoshone]

ok,

for me that of the first photography is a male predominant, that of the second photography is a male dominated.

 

[Mike Wise]

They look like A. macmasteri to me. Body shape and coloration are mac's.

 

[Mburz]

Thanks to everyone for their input