Which sexe are the nannacara anomala

[bijouxcailloux]

everyone,

We just bought a trio nannacara, hopping for maybe a small harem but more we watch them evolving in the tank and more we have fears that we have 3 males.

One for sure, clearly the alpha, but for the two others there are some doubts, maybe a male in costume or femelle?

I can make more pictures if needed
Have a good day all

 

[dw1305]

Hi all,
Welcome to Apistogramma forums.

and more we have fears that we have 3 males.

With the traditional disclaimer that I'm really poor at sexing (and identification), but if they have any blue "shiny" scales? They are all males.

cheers Darrel

 

[Mike Wise]

They all look like males to me, although the fish in the first photo just might be female. Disclaimer: I haven't kept nor bred N. anomala since the 1980s.

 

[Apistomaster]

Haven't kept N. anomala since 1970 but I think you have two young males.

 

[bijouxcailloux]

Hello there!

They really are funny cuties!
You would have ask me 4 hours ago, I would have say we have 3 males, 2 clearly and one dominated.
But today we did a water change and fed with live food, and what we thought to be dominated male act like a female. She was going and coming to one the male until he followed her to a corner of the aquarium, but she was clearly going after him and made sure he was following.
So we are a bit confused, because it seems it's a female but she/he has some blue reflections..
Here is the latest picture.
Maybe you'd like to shar your opinion even if it was long ago!

 

[Apistomaster]

Now I'm not sure because they do look like a pair to me. What a fun game these fish make us play. Is she or is he?

 

[bijouxcailloux]

For sure it's funny, today I am not so sure that we have a female... Only time will help I guess!

 

[bijouxcailloux]

Hello

Small news from the nannacaras!

It happened that we had indeed 3 males, so yesterday we switched one male for a female (because two males have their territory).

For now we think that the new one is a female, the caudale's end is round and no trace of blue on the scales.

I expected a warm welcome from the males but it seems they don't want to share their place with the female, and the poor one just have to swim away. I thought that male and female could share territories, any opinions?



In case or the situation don't go better we have the option to take one male away.

Wish you

a good day!

 

[Mike Wise]

If you didn't do it, you should have re-arranged the tank decor before adding another territorial fish. The other 2 fish have established territories to their mutual satisfaction and another territorial fish is not welcome.

 

[bijouxcailloux]

Ah true! I forget this tip!
But do they not share territories between male and female?

 

[MacZ]

No, usually a male has a fixed territory and only allows females ready to breed in it. If the female isn't receptive to his advances she is chased off. And this might be a problem in this case because worst case she is chased from one territory to the other and welcome in neither, resulting in stress, sickness, death.

 

[anewbie]

The nannacara anomala I've owned have not been as territorial as some species of apistogramma. They aren't really pair forming but i've never been able to keep more than one female. My sample is small - 3 males but i would say my experience is they are more passive. The female with fry is another story.

 

[bijouxcailloux]

Thank you all for sharing your experience.
We indeed change the decoration (which is a big bunch of leaves) and it created a small peacefull place for the female to be without being constantly chase. The two males did kept their position, one on the left one on the right and the female in the middle.
We keep a close eyes on her because she was also not on her best shape from the shop.
Let's see how things evolve with time, but for now there is for sure 2 males and one female! Easy to see the differences!

 

[JManning]

everyone,

We just bought a trio nannacara, hopping for maybe a small harem but more we watch them evolving in the tank and more we have fears that we have 3 males.

One for sure, clearly the alpha, but for the two others there are some doubts, maybe a male in costume or femelle?

I can make more pictures if needed
Have a good day all

i'm not positive but you might have all males, where did you get yours I am currently looking for a male to go with my girls and can't seem to find any at the moment

 

[bijouxcailloux]

i'm not positive but you might have all males, where did you get yours I am currently looking for a male to go with my girls and can't seem to find any at the moment

Hi there!
We did have 3 males, we exchange one male for one female from the shop.
So far our 2 males had there territory but since one week, the smaller males lost his position and we would like to give him a new home.
We are by the corner of Switzerland, Germany and France!
Your message give us hope as well!!

 

[anewbie]

i'm not positive but you might have all males, where did you get yours I am currently looking for a male to go with my girls and can't seem to find any at the moment

If you are in USA wetspot has some domestic in stock; they are label as small unsexed but you can ask if they can identify one as a male.